It seems to me as if both would do equally bad. I doubt I have to explain the faults of BioWare, but as far as CD Projekt is concerned, just look at the MASSIVE downgrade that Assassins Of Kings was in comparison to The Witcher. They show the same degeneracy that BioWare does, but their series is based on a book and isn't a party RPG. I'm frankly amazed that there wasn't a huge customer backlash regarding Assassins Of Kings, when their entire PR campaign prior to the game's release was based on not being another streamlined console port, while the product delivered was exactly that - streamlined in every possible manner. And my grievances here aren't as much with the gameplay, I can live with that, it's that the entirely unique universe of The Witcher was turned into another generic fantasy world, losing the genuine Slavic touch that made the first game's world so unique.
Might be a good idea, as long as they go from a clean slate rather than making a Bioshock crossover.
The people behind Thiaf?
I didn't play anything of theirs other than Shadowrun Returns, and that one seemed more focused on mechanics than choices, consequences and lore. But if we're looking for a necessarily isometric Fallout, there are worse choices.
They might do better in the non-stealth genre. I'm tired of typing so I declare that I basically agree with this review:
